Meet Our Staff


Kevin Hay

Lead Pastor

Kevin was called to be the Lead Pastor of First Baptist in 2018. He graduated from Shawnee State University (2007) with a Bachelor’s degree in Sports Studies. He graduated from Southwestern Baptist Theological Seminary (2020) with a Master of Divinity, and he is currently pursuing his Doctor of Ministry in Expository Preaching from The Master's Seminary. Kevin has been serving in pastoral ministry since 2009 and loves helping people come to know God and grow in their relationship with Jesus through the faithful teaching and preaching of God’s Word. As a shepherd, Kevin seeks to care for the souls who have been entrusted to him. He is passionate about cultivating growth and giftedness in the church and leading the church in making disciples. Kevin is married to Alicia, and together they have seven children: McKenna, Landon, Meela, Madison, Liam, Levi, and Mariah. In his free time, Kevin enjoys traveling, playing games and taking walks with his family, watching and playing sports, especially basketball and soccer, reading books on theology, writing, and drinking coffee.

Denise Matthews

Office Administrator & Treasurer

Denise has been the FBC office administrator/church treasurer for over 35 years.  Both she and her husband, Gayle, came from a Catholic background, and joined First Baptist in 1977. She has seen many changes in the church from personnel and programs to major construction projects. She has been married to Gayle for 48 years and has two daughters and 5 grandchildren from ages 5-18. Denise has held many positions on the different boards in the church and has had enormous pleasure working with others and making many friendships within the church family. She considers herself blessed and hopefully has been a blessing to others. For 6 years, Denise, along with her husband Gayle had a family hobby of drag racing. Both of them competed on the race track and would bring the whole family along!  

Michael Pepper


Mike has been our custodian at FBC for a year. For those of you who haven't had the pleasure of meeting Mike, he is a humble and joyful soul. He is passionate about knowing the Lord more deeply, and worshipping Him. He sees the beauty of God in all of creation, which leads him to enjoy an active lifestyle such as riding his bike on the Cardinal Greenway. In Mike's free time, aside from exercise, you will find him reading, serving, or researching a new joke. His desire is to live a life of youthfulness and compassion for others. It wouldn't be an interaction with Mike unless you walked away with a riddle or joke, so, what time did God create Adam?